The “Golden Cage” (2015)

In January 2015, a magistrate decided that Oslo Accords are no more in force. At the time of writing, he is no more looking into cases (as he was transferred as execution judge!).

Is it the power of Oslo?!

Apparently, not only the PA is attached to it, even the ‘judiciary’ considers Oslo Accords sacred texts! By the Oslo Accords, the PA – and the Palestinian courts – indeed has no jurisdiction on Israeli citizens – even those from Palestinian origin.

In fact Oslo created two systems: one is valid for the occupier’s citizens, and another for the rest – defined in negative as Non-Israelis.

I suspect, we, Palestinians, are trapped by Oslo, to the point we cannot even think of ourselves without such “golden cage” – which is not of gold, of course! Are we, Palestinians, living the post-colonial trauma? The sad thing is that we live the trauma before ending the colonial regime!

Israel, in fact, created a system where law, ethnicity & power are so entrenched; making it incomparable to typical occupation or apartheid regimes.

It is true that sometimes many, including Palestinians with good intentions of course, prefer to compare Palestine to South Africa where Palestinians are considered the “new black”! I, personally, don’t think this is completely accurate.

Look at the Palestinians holding Israeli citizenship. They often face discrimination inside the state which defines itself as Jewish state, Israel. But those “Arab-Israelis” when in the occupied Palestinian territory, they are immune from PA jurisdiction, valid for non-Israelis only! So they are neither “white” nor “black”, within the apartheid paradigm.

Accordingly, South Africa’s apartheid paradigm isn’t accurate to describe the Israeli regime in occupied Palestine. Of course, being different doesn’t mean better. Israeli occupation regime is as discriminatory as South Africa under Apartheid. Still the South African Apartheid paradigm doesn’t tell the whole story.

So how can we define Israeli regime in the occupied Palestinian territory?

Palestinians need to find their own paradigm, to tell their story, and tell it properly.

To read the decision in Arabic نص قرار الأشقر.

Ps. This blog was published in 18 January 2015. It needs still to be edited. Please do not quote.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s